How to build a two-sided marketplace with the Yelp model… and why Craigslist hates it!

| November 24, 2012 | 5 Comments

I’ve talked about the chicken and egg problem in seeding two-sided marketplaces at length earlier. Producers won’t show up without Consumers and vice versa. One of the models that I’d proposed, that works especially well for startups like ShopKick is to build the value proposition in such a manner that your producers bring in the consumers. Another way of building a two-sided marketplace is to do it the other way round: Focus on the consumers and leverage their interest to bring in the producers. The pattern for implementing this is, in my opinion, an extension of the model originally made famous by Yelp.


The Yelp Model

Yelp is an online local search service that allows consumers to search for businesses, read reviews and make decisions accordingly. Yelp starts with a searchable directory of local businesses and uses that to gather search traffic. Once there’s enough traffic coming in, it pitches the search leads to businesses which are getting a lot of search-generated views or whose category is a common search term. E.g. restaurants in San Francisco. With the traffic-backed pitch, the businesses are brought on board to claim their listing and advertise for related search terms. Over time, this builds up the producer side of the network.

So that’s special because?

Two-sided markets have a problem because they require synchronization of producers and consumers coming onto the platform for interactions to happen. Since getting both sides in sufficient numbers simultaneously is almost impossible to execute, most marketplaces and platforms try to stage the seeding process getting one side in after the other. The Yelp model is particularly interesting because the staging doesn’t require expensive incentives etc. and doesn’t need to be coordinated in quick succession as consumers get value from Yelp’s search engine even when the merchants aren’t on board.


The problem is Yelp’s model isn’t applicable to most marketplace startups because they do not necessarily offer a standalone value proposition like directory search. Most marketplaces start with the aim of matching buyers to sellers and actually need both sides to be on board. However, with a few tweaks, the essential principles of Yelp’s model can still be applied to a broader range of platforms and marketplaces.


The Generalized Yelp Model

The Generalized Yelp Model takes a leaf from Yelp’s playbook and takes the following route:


Supply Proxies


Supply proxies are data points that represent true supply but that are not actually created by the producer. The platform, hence, doesn’t own the supply side yet. The idea, ultimately, is to have producers come and claim their supply proxies and eventually create more supply on the  platform.

In the case of Yelp, the supply proxies were the directory listings. In the case of TripAdvisor, the supply proxies are the hotel or restaurant listings. Also, the Yelp model works because it takes the Yellow pages model and adds an extra layer of functionality: search. Search makes the value proposition much stronger and the product more user-friendly.

In recent times, several niche marketplaces have emerged leveraging this model. Most of these follow the same pattern: Source listings from Craigslist, create a better search and navigation experience, draw traffic and convert to leads. Craigslist (in)famously has caught on to the trend and has been sending cease and desist letters.

The Craigslist case notwithstanding, this continues to be a great model for startups with great technology but a distribution problem to work around their distribution.


Making It Work

There are, of course, several factors that determine the success of this model:

  1. The original source of data points: The relevance of the marketplace depends on the strength and quality of listings that are scraped. Local commerce startups may rely on yellow pages but YPs are often outdated.
  2. Legalities of scraping: Craigslist doesn’t like it. Just be sure you’re sticking fingers into the right pie.
  3. Ability to provide a better transaction experience: The marketplace that uses the scraped listings should have compelling improvements in what it offers to the producer to attract the producer away from the marketplace she is currently using. This could include frictionless and secure transactions, better customer management, a more targeted and niche community more relevant to the producer etc.
  4. Ability to own the transaction: All the above are pointless unless the marketplace can own the transaction. In many ways, the ability to own the transaction and manage it end-to-end acts as the value proposition for producers as well as a guaranteed revenue stream for the platform itself.

Have you tried using this model or variations of it?

If you liked reading this post, you might want to get a free digital copy of the forthcoming book PLATFORMED.


About the Author:

  • rolex replica watches

    The best ones create value for the supply before sending them the demand
    which allows the marketplaces to build a critical mass of supply
    whereby it becomes truly valuable for consumers and network effects

  • Valen

    greate article! Recently is becoming super popular and it seems that they’re using the way that you recommend in this article: getting the consumers to list the products from online stores or ETSY shops via URL and later on pitch shops to claim their store page on Wanelo. I’m trying to build a fashion C2C marketplace and also facing the same “chicken and egg” problems here and I’m thinking if i can adopt the same method. the biggest issue that im facing if i want to go this way is in my country, most of the online fashion sellers are selling on Instagram, in this case users are not able to share the product onto my website using URL link since IG’s photo cannot be captured via image link that IG is providing. Any advice on this issue? many thanks!

  • finestglasses j.

    Get Trendier by buying oval Eyeglasses is easy.  Just search at google, find a cheap and good quality women oval glasses at Since it is cheap, buying 3 differs oval eyeglasses with 3 differ colors. 

  • Aaron Wolf

    “All the above are pointless unless the marketplace can own the transaction.” Um, what about all the *points* about the value of “the above” ? Creating value is pointless unless you get rich or powerful off it?

  • Ryan Baptiste

    Amazing site! #inlove

    By (scraping) supplying product on behalf of the producers to fill one side of the market place to create usage at first…. In order to gain traction and entice other local producers to join at a cost… Once this objective is fulfilled, would it look poorly by now removing the scraped data supply of the initial producers in order to charge them for usage in the marketplace?