For a network business to succeed, the right producers need to be matched with the right consumers. The likelihood of having both the right producers and the right consumers for all possible transactions increases as the size of the user base increases. This makes it particularly difficult for a new startup to take off because there might not be enough members of both sides (or in both roles) to spark interactions. Critical mass is the minimum size of the user base at which enough number of producers and consumers exist to spark transactions sustainably.
It’s Not About Scale
What would have been a greater success for Foursquare in its earlier days:
State A: 100000 users with 1000 users/city in 100 cities
State B: 50000 users in New York
FourSquare succeeded because it focused on one city till it reached critical mass. Getting users across multiple cities would not have helped spark interactions among users leading to low engagement and eventual drop-off.
While it is easier to see the effect of such fragmentation in terms of geo-locations, any platform that doesn’t target its user acquisition activity and its proposition risks ending up in State A above.
Why is it important to reach Critical Mass?
Critical mass is a happy state where:
1. Producers are producing, users are contributing
2. There is enough user-generated content/products/listings to keep consumers hooked
3. Consumers interact with producers and products and return for more
In such a scenario:
1. There is high virility as users start bringing in other users. Producers bring in others to show off their products/contributions. Consumers bring in other because they get benefited.
2. Retention is higher as users are satisfied
For a business to makes sense, the Cost of Acquisition of a Customer (CAC) should be lower than the Life Time Value of the Customer (LTV). Before a platform reaches critical mass,
1. CAC is high because virility hasn’t kicked in and users aren’t inviting other users
2. LTV is low because users who visit and do not see relevant activity abandon the system
Clearly, if this state persists, it results in a drain on resources with low business viability. This is the primary reason why a lot of platform startups never take off and fizzle off after burning VC money.
Hacking Your Way Towards Critical Mass
Lowering Critical Mass
Successful companies solve this problem by focusing their initial efforts at user acquisition to create the right mix and lower the critical mass required.
1. This problem is solved by targeting a niche. A niche that has both consumers and producers can support a platform a a lower critical mass. E.g. it is easier to solve a social network targeted at startups with a specific call to action than a general purpose social network.
2. Groupon grew big because it figured an interesting solution to the critical mass problem. However, as it soon turned out, the solution wasn’t sustainable. This is the reason why so many Groupon clones mushroomed all across the world (low barrier to entry) but most of them vanished within a few months despite having VC money to burn (owing to high barriers to scale).
Hacking User Contribution
If you are a platform dependent on user-generated content but do not have distinct producer and consumer roles, then it is critical that user on the platform start contributing to it. YouTube would have been useless if early users hadn’t contributed. This ties back to The Ghost Town Problem. Hence, it is important to accelerate production by every design hack possible.
Making the users look good is a great growth strategy. Provide them tools of self-expression so they’ll want to spread the word about what they create, and in doing so, about the platform. Youtube ‘s growth is spurred by every video that goes viral on it. Users, in promoting the video, end up promoting the platform.
Provide Producer-Friendly Infrastructure
Critical mass is also gained at a faster pace if the platform is designed in a way that the producers bring in the consumers. This is best achieved when your platform provides the means to distribute content/products (e.g. embeds from Youtube) and the ability to better interact with consumers (e.g. m-Loyalty)